Shipping to CT
Red WineWhite WineRosé WineSparkling WineMixed Wine$30+$20-$30$15-$20TrioSixTwelveGold Medal RedsGold Medal MixBordeaux RescueWorld Class Spring RoséView AllBROWSE ALL MIXED CASESRed WineWhite WineRosé WineChampagne & SparklingDessert WineArgentinaAustraliaChileFranceItalyNew ZealandPortugalSouth AfricaSpainUSABordeauxBurgundyCaliforniaLoire ValleyMendozaPiedmontProseccoRhôneRiojaTuscanyVenetoCabernet SauvignonChardonnayMalbecMerlotMontepulcianoMoscatoPinot GrigioPinot NoirRieslingSauvignon BlancSyrah/ShirazZinfandelSOMM TV CollectionsLow AlcoholFine Wines90 Point WineDry Red WineAward Winning Red WinesAward Winning White WinesBordeaux Red Wine Gift SetItaly Lovers Gift BoxTop Rated Red WinesTop Rated White WinesBiodynamicOrganic GrapesVeganVegetarianBROWSE ALL WINESBROWSE LATEST OFFERSClassic Red & White WinesClassic Red WinesPremium Red WinesHost GiftsBirthdayThank YouWeddingCorporate GiftingBoutique Bubbly SixWine & Cheese Lovers' Gift SetBest-Selling Reds SixBest-Selling Whites SixWine Gift BagsSlate Cheese BoardDartington DecanterRechargeable CorkscrewCrystal Champagne FlutesFrench-Style Steak KnivesBROWSE ALL GIFTSWine Color and Its MeaningWine Temperature Serving GuideRed Wine vs White WineWine Longevity After OpeningUnderstanding Wine AcidityTypes of Wine GlassesView AllGift Ideas For Wine LoversHow to Choose the Best WineAre Wine Clubs Worth It?Easy Champagne Cocktails to Make in MinutesWine Club BenefitsChoosing Wine for DessertsBest Wine with PastaPairing Wine with ChickenBest Wine with HamTurkey and Wine PairingView AllSOMM TV CollectionsNY Jets Uncorked Legacy WinePride Blend: Support the American LGBTQ+ MuseumView AllBROWSE ALL ARTICLES
  • Home
  • All wines
  • Customer Choice Reds

Customer Choice Reds

Everyday Favorites and Rich Reserves
4.3 Average bottle rating
This case gets you some of the reds our customers rate the highest and like the best, paired with the long-aged, luxe upgrades of each. (You’ll get two of every favorite included, matched with one bottle of its Reserve edition.)
Customer Choice Reds
$257.88$199.88
12 Bottles

Case Contents

Pagos de Tahola Rioja 2023

Regular price: $17.99 per bottle
Top-Estate, Gold-Medal Rioja

Wine Details

Gold
  • Red - Medium Bodied
  • SpainSpain
  • Tempranillo
  • 14% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 28 February 2027
Pagos de Tahola Rioja

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Pagos de Tahola is a medium-bodied red with ripe strawberry, plum and subtle oak aromas. Vibrant and fresh, the palate delivers juicy red-berry flavors and a complex, smooth finish.
Wine Food Pairings
Beef, pork, firm cheeses, red-sauced pastas, vegetarian meals.

Pagos de Tahola Rioja Reserva 2017

Regular price: $29.99 per bottle
Perfectly Aged Rioja Reserva

Wine Details

Pagos de Tahola Rioja Reserva

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Pagos de Tahola Reserva is a medium-bodied red wine with ripe red berry and complex vanilla aromas. The palate delivers cherry, red currant and plum flavors, with notes of spice and classic, earthy leather on the long finish.
Wine Food Pairings
Beef, pork, firm cheeses, red-sauced pastas, vegetarian meals.

Stones & Bones 2023

Regular price: $16.99 per bottle
Best-Selling Portuguese Blockbuster

Wine Details

Gold
92
92PTS
  • Red - Full Bodied
  • PortugalPortugal
  • Touriga Nacional-based blend
  • Vegan
  • 14% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 31 December 2027
Stones & Bones

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Stones & Bones is a full-bodied red wine with intense aromas of ripe berries and sweet spice. The palate offers black plum and bramble fruit flavors framed by toasty-smoky oak notes.
Wine Food Pairings
Tapas, cured meat/charcuterie, lamb, game, chorizo, roasted vegetables, firm cheeses.

Tenuta Fenice Nero d’Avola 2024

Regular price: $19.99 per bottle
Historic Sicilian Nero d’Avola

Wine Details

Silver
Tenuta Fenice Nero d’Avola

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Tenuta Fenice is a medium- to full-bodied red wine with richly perfumed aromas of dark berries and sweet spices. The palate delivers ripe blackberry and cherry flavors, plus hints of licorice. Long, silky and satisfying finish.
Wine Food Pairings
Red meat, pasta with meatballs, grilled white fish, barbecue (esp. ribs), baked pasta dishes.

Tenuta Fenice Riserva 2022

Regular price: $26.99 per bottle
Old-Vine Sicilian Riserva

Wine Details

  • Red - Full Bodied
  • ItalyItaly
  • Red blend
  • Vegan
  • 14% ABV
  • 750 ml
  • Vegetarian
  • 31 December 2028
Tenuta Fenice Riserva

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Tenuta Fenice Riserva is a medium-bodied red wine with plum and sour cherry accented by strawberry, blackberry and sweet spice. Warming and smooth, it’s well balanced, with a long, satisfying finish.
Wine Food Pairings
Red meat, pasta with meatballs, grilled white fish, barbecue (esp. ribs), baked pasta dishes.

Stones & Bones Reserva 2023

Regular price: $24.99 per bottle
Fine Portuguese Reserva

Wine Details

Stones & Bones Reserva

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Stones & Bones Reserva is a full-bodied red wine with aromas of ripe red fruit and spicy oak notes. The luscious palate offers rich dark fruit and vanilla flavors, plus silky tannins and a long finish.
Wine Food Pairings
Hearty stews (with or without meat), barbecue, pork, meaty pastas, aged cheeses.

Black Saint Peter Zinfandel Reserve 2023

Regular price: $25.99 per bottle
Old-Vine Zinfandel Reserve

Wine Details

Silver
Black Saint Peter Zinfandel Reserve

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Black Saint Peter Reserve is a full-bodied red wine with expressive bramble fruit and cocoa powder aromas. The palate is rich, with ripe black plum, black cherry, fig and baking spice flavors, and smooth tannins.
Wine Food Pairings
Grilled steak, barbecue, burgers, turkey, pork, spicy dishes (esp. with Cajun seasonings), eggplant, meaty pasta dishes.

Black Saint Peter Old Vine Zinfandel 2023

Regular price: $19.99 per bottle
Bestselling Lodi Zinfandel

Wine Details

Silver
Black Saint Peter Old Vine Zinfandel

Flavor Profile

Wine Flavor Profile
Black Saint Peter is a full-bodied red wine with intense aromas of spicy red fruit, plus hints of pepper, mint and sweet spice. On the palate, look for smooth, mouthfilling flavors of black cherry and bramble fruits, layered with sweet vanilla oak.
Wine Food Pairings
Grilled steak, barbecue, burgers, turkey, pork, spicy dishes (esp. with Cajun seasonings), eggplant, meaty pasta dishes.